ALTHOUGH I try to hide it, I’m a bit of a Doctor Who fan, and tonight was a big date in this year’s calendar for me – the latest in David Tenant’s hour-long specials.
Waters of Mars tried to be – and was largely successful in being – a straightforward Alien-like thriller. It was tense and stylish, though not anywhere near as scary as predicted by the outgoing showrunner, Russell “the T” Davies. On another level, it returned to the occasionally-visited theme of the Doctor being the last of the Timelords and what that actually means (other than his achieving WWF status as an endangered species).

Tenant has explored this terrain before, most notably in his first appearance in the role, when he killed the leader of the Sycorax in 2005’s The Christmas Invasion, warning him: “No second chances.” This was a new facet of the character; more ruthless, less patient. Unfortunately, for most of the rest of Tenant’s reign in the Tardis, he was more like the traditional character: superior, compassionate, willing to offer that second chance to any enemy who needed it.
In Waters of Mars the Doctor finally seemed to succumb to the inevitable arrogance that most people would associate with the title “Timelord”; he actually started inventing his own rules and saying “tough” whenever someone disagreed with him. That would have been a fascinating direction to take his character. but at the very end he seemed to revert to his more familiar and safe “white hat” mode, which was a pity.
A very good episode, though, and miles better than the disappointing Planet of the Dead.
Of course, the trailer for the Christmas special, The End of Time, must have whetted every viewer’s appetite for Tenant’s curtain call in the title role. And John Sim’s back as the Master! I’ll blog, one of these days, about the drunken conversation I had with him a couple of years ago.














Sunday 15 November 2009 at 10:39 pm
I’m generally wary of the Dr Who specials they tend to be, in my view rather patchy but tonight’s was a decent one.
Agree also it wasn’t as scary as billed, certainly no episode has come as close to the superb ‘Blink’ for pure tension.
Sunday 15 November 2009 at 10:58 pm
It was a good episode. I agree with Tom (for once), the flash of megalomania would have been very interesting for the character to explore. Alas I can’t see it happening once he regenerates into the new lad. Shame.
Sunday 15 November 2009 at 11:01 pm
I thought Dr Who was a childrens programe.
People stop watching it when they grow up.
but not Tom.
Sunday 15 November 2009 at 11:37 pm
I find myself wondering why I am not desperate to see this episode.
I think “Planet of the Dead” finished it for me.
It was put together by people who,after a particularly heavy session of snorting cocaine, I should think, said “Hey, let’s take a London Bus out to the desert” “Yeah, let’s do that, and have Wonderwoman come down from the ceiling on a rope” “Yeah, let’s do that”. And, “Let’s have the bus filled with just the right politically correct demographic, only, as an edgy twist, make the black people… OLD!” “F**K Yeah!”
Dr Who is super-ann-u-a-TED (Dalek Voice). Now that the initial shock has worn off – that they actually spent money on the show – that is now all it is really about.
A regeneration may save it. The jury is out.
Monday 16 November 2009 at 2:58 am
@Johnny Norfolk
Dr Who is one of those programmes that appeals to all ages, just as Lord of the Rings does.
The original Dr Who (Drs 1 to 3) were, in my opinion, the best though the new series has its moments. I watch it on DVD so I a little behind the times.
Something for everyone or most everyone.
Monday 16 November 2009 at 8:40 am
I was a little disappointed with it. It certainly wasn’t as scary as billed, and there was very little build-up of tension.
The character change, to me, came across more as a plot device. Since we all know David Tenant is leaving, I think it could have been handled more subtley.
In general, I am more of a Steven Moffat fan, and find his stories better written, and, dare I say it, more intelligent than those of Russel T Davies’.
I am definately looking forward to the new series with Moffat at the helm.
Monday 16 November 2009 at 9:12 am
Tom
But will we have to be Drunk to understand the conversation.
you will have to forwarn us so we can prepare in a the proper manner.
PS
bought 15 cans of lager from sainsburys for £10 bargain eh! they were 550 ml ones as well not your normal piddly little 440ml.
Monday 16 November 2009 at 9:44 am
Dr Who loomed very large in the Saturdays of my very early childhood. My teenage brother and his mate wanted to watch it, and they used to mostly hoot with laughter at it, although sometimes they’d go a bit quiet and shocked. The episodes of the early 60s seemed truly terrifying, because of a horrific sense of claustrophobia it conjured up, and the fact that the screen itself was small and in black and white lent itself to that. There seemed to be an awful lot of running down corridors pursued by a Dalek. And worst of all, the bit where someone would get exterminated and the screen would go negative to their sound of their screams. Lovely teatime viewing! Strangely enough, the other kids at my nursery all seemed to watch it as well, and one little boy brought a toy Dalek in one day, which had lots of the little girls screaming in genuine terror once it started moving about waving its antennae.
I watched Who throughout my childhood and teens – really good programmes with a limited budget, and being amazingly imaginative and innovative within those tight limits. Watching some of the old 70s stuff for example, you can see how it would make a really good film if it wasn’t let down by its limited production values.
These days, I think they’ve got the opposite situation – of great production values, but often rather limited ideas.
Monday 16 November 2009 at 9:56 am
Ah Tom,
Agree with you! I would have liked the new arragant Dr to have progressed to the next special in which he would/could have faced the problems that associate with being THE timelord!
Sent shivers down my spine knowing that he went all “My rules, Tough!” then the epiphany at the end was a bit
Ah well, all excited for the next one though!
Monday 16 November 2009 at 9:59 am
I agree that this wasn’t as obviously unsettling as it had been made out to be, but it was still sublimely distressing.
Midnight – with a beastie which went knock-a-knock a lot – was sick.
Monday 16 November 2009 at 10:33 am
Chris Wills
I used to watch and enjoy when I was a child. But come on there are other things as you grow up. I suppose its just like the rest of the country that does not want to grow up.
Monday 16 November 2009 at 10:44 am
Of course, Children of Earth was *vile*.
PS *How* many beats did the Master’s ditty have, and what’s this with John Simm looking like a debauched Roman Emperor?
Monday 16 November 2009 at 10:55 am
The Master’s “ditty” was actually the Doctor Who theme tune: dum-de-de-dum, dum-de-de-dum…
Monday 16 November 2009 at 10:55 am
Johnny, unless you were a child in 2005, you’re not comparing like with like. Seriously.
Monday 16 November 2009 at 10:55 am
Yeah, but four beats!
Monday 16 November 2009 at 12:21 pm
Enjoyed last night and I think I was right in not allowing my five-year-old to watch it.
I think the arrogance was part of his realisation that his time is coming to an end and thought, as the last time lord, that the rules would not apply to him and he could keep going.
That’s if he’s really the last of the timelords that is…
Yeah, I know Sims is back but I mean the rest of Gallifrey!
What do you think of Moorcock writing a Who novel then Tom?
Monday 16 November 2009 at 12:35 pm
@Johnny,
Like the government, the BBC couldn’t just let children be children, they had to update Dr Who for the modern generation. You know, a bit of swearing and ‘gay’ characters, that sort of thing.
Monday 16 November 2009 at 12:40 pm
You’ve forgotten the bumper special where Soutec, Roger Delgado and Michael Ashcroft tied him up in our coal bunker then . . ?
Monday 16 November 2009 at 5:32 pm
@Johnny Norfolk
Nothing wrong with some escapism
I do prefer the early original series, as I mentioned.
But the new one is better than the final series from the olden times when the BBC decided to play it for laughs so they could kill it off.
Monday 16 November 2009 at 7:31 pm
I had one big complaint: at times the music was so load that it obliterated all the speech! Really annnoyed SWMBO and myself!
Wednesday 18 November 2009 at 3:28 pm
@ Tom
“The Master’s “ditty” was actually the Doctor Who theme tune: dum-de-de-dum, dum-de-de-dum…”
Sorry to be a pedant, Tom, but Russell T Davies has said it was actually the beat of his alarm clock in the morning. Sorry!
A good episode, that finally gave Tennant the chance to make good on the no second chances promise of The Christmas Invasion, although the music was over-loud and in appropriate, and the action film stuff near the end detracted from the overall feel.
Was is just me, or was the teaser trailer actually quite disappointing? Where’s Timothy Dalton in his (SPOILER!) gear? What about Rose, Jack, Martha and Sarah Jane clips? And how about a bit of action?
Leave a comment